PASS

Mason re-check — Foundry Pack System v0 outputs (2026-05-02)

Task: 2ceaa43b-960b-4382-8001-4d4d949ee3ce Checker: Mason (independent local re-check only)

Commands run

sed -n '1,220p' /Users/lilly/clawd/templates/mc-briefs/infrastructure.md
sed -n '1,240p' /Users/lilly/clawd/projects/foundry-commercialisation/packs/mason-pack-system-check-2026-05-02.md
sed -n '1,260p' /Users/lilly/clawd/projects/foundry-commercialisation/packs/pack-system-v0-contract.md
sed -n '1,220p' /Users/lilly/clawd/projects/foundry-commercialisation/packs/pdf-ops-pack/evidence/mapping-approved-hermes-evidence.md
sed -n '1,240p' /Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-foundry-pack-runtime-spine-manifest-permissions-doctor-support-bundle/README.md
sed -n '1,240p' /Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-pdf-ops-reference-pack-contents-for-hermes-workflow/README.md
sed -n '1,260p' /Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-pdf-ops-pack-run-path-flight-recorder-evidence-spine/DELIVERABLE.md
find /Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-pdf-ops-pack-run-path-flight-recorder-evidence-spine -maxdepth 2 -type f | sort
cd /Users/lilly/clawd/projects/foundry-core && PYTHONPATH=src pytest -q tests/test_pack_runtime.py tests/test_cli.py tests/test_daemon.py
cd /Users/lilly/clawd/projects/foundry-core && PYTHONPATH=src pytest -q tests/test_cli.py -k 'test_cli_doctor_reports_packaging_health or test_cli_pack_install_check_and_support_bundle_are_truthful'
cd /Users/lilly/clawd/projects/foundry-core && rg -n "declared-not-proven|support-bundle|pack install|pack check|pack run|resolved_permissions|outbound.send|demo-only|partial|pack_ready|route_status|permission_summary" src tests
python3 - <<'PY'
import json, pathlib
for p in [
  pathlib.Path('/Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-pdf-ops-pack-run-path-flight-recorder-evidence-spine/03-pack-run.json'),
  pathlib.Path('/Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-pdf-ops-pack-run-path-flight-recorder-evidence-spine/run-2026-05-02T08-08-00Z-310989a2/03-run.json'),
  pathlib.Path('/Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-pdf-ops-pack-run-path-flight-recorder-evidence-spine/run-2026-05-02T08-08-00Z-310989a2/05-permissions.json'),
  pathlib.Path('/Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-pdf-ops-pack-run-path-flight-recorder-evidence-spine/run-2026-05-02T08-08-00Z-310989a2/12-no-cloud-posture.json'),
  pathlib.Path('/Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-pdf-ops-pack-run-path-flight-recorder-evidence-spine/run-2026-05-02T08-08-00Z-310989a2/10-flight-recorder-events.json'),
]:
    print(p)
    print(p.read_text())
PY
sed -n '352,359p' /Users/lilly/clawd/agents/polly/memory/2026-05-02.md

Re-check result

The earlier red-gate reasons are resolved. The test gate is green, the PDF Ops mapping row is truthful, and the MC metadata correction is documented. The three deliverable sets still exist distinctly and the install -> check -> run -> route -> permissions -> evals -> Flight Recorder chain remains real.

Final verdict: PASS

Task 1 — runtime spine

Status: PASS

Evidence:

cd /Users/lilly/clawd/projects/foundry-core && PYTHONPATH=src pytest -q tests/test_pack_runtime.py tests/test_cli.py tests/test_daemon.py -> 16 passed in 5.77s
cd /Users/lilly/clawd/projects/foundry-core && PYTHONPATH=src pytest -q tests/test_cli.py -k 'test_cli_doctor_reports_packaging_health or test_cli_pack_install_check_and_support_bundle_are_truthful' -> 2 passed, 3 deselected in 1.69s
src/foundry_core/pack_runtime.py still proves:
manifest validation
grouped permission resolution with explicit outbound.send default deny
foundry pack install/check/run/support-bundle
declared-not-proven route honesty
install modes partial / demo-only / ready
pack-aware support summary and persisted pack state
Runtime-spine evidence folder remains distinct:
/Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-foundry-pack-runtime-spine-manifest-permissions-doctor-support-bundle/

Task 2 — PDF Ops pack contents

Status: PASS

Evidence:

Pack contents remain distinct under:
/Users/lilly/clawd/projects/foundry-commercialisation/packs/pdf-ops-pack/
/Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-pdf-ops-reference-pack-contents-for-hermes-workflow/README.md
mapping-approved-hermes-evidence.md now truthfully maps:
03-run.json -> /Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-pdf-ops-pack-run-path-flight-recorder-evidence-spine/run-2026-05-02T08-08-00Z-310989a2/03-run.json
wording says it is the native artifact emitted by foundry pack run pdf-ops-pack --demo --json
Outbound send remains disabled by default in the mapping and runtime evidence:
05-permissions.json shows outbound.send.state = denied
12-no-cloud-posture.json shows outbound_send_default_denied = true

Task 3 — run path / Flight Recorder evidence spine

Status: PASS

Evidence:

Run-path evidence folder remains distinct:
/Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-pdf-ops-pack-run-path-flight-recorder-evidence-spine/
Common spine plus PDF-specific outputs exist in the verified run directory:
00-pack-manifest.yaml
01-install.json
02-check.json
03-run.json
04-route-status.json
05-permissions.json
06-evals.json
07-truthful-limitations.md
08-support-summary.md
09-human-review-events.json
09-pdf-demo-report.json
10-flight-recorder-events.json
10-signed-pdf-report.json
11-index-query-report.json
12-no-cloud-posture.json
Root run result is complete:
/Users/lilly/Documents/Shared/projects/build-pdf-ops-pack-run-path-flight-recorder-evidence-spine/03-pack-run.json -> ok: true, status: completed, run ID 310989a2-2c62-41d2-aa05-5fbd61fe526c
Verified run artifact shows no block:
run-2026-05-02T08-08-00Z-310989a2/03-run.json -> blocked_reasons: []
Flight Recorder order is present and truthful:
pack.run.requested
pack.run.route_decisions
pack.run.human_review
pack.run.permissions
pack.run.pdf_evidence
pack.run.completed
Route honesty is preserved:
route readiness values are still declared-not-proven, not silently green

MC metadata correction

Status: PASS

Evidence:

sed -n '352,359p' /Users/lilly/clawd/agents/polly/memory/2026-05-02.md records the correction loop and states:
task ecb1a8d2-4fb7-426a-924f-e0ac6a40ea09 now describes the PDF Ops reference pack contents deliverable with output URL to its README
task c9121bf3-75c9-4f42-a4a8-37c1337adad4 now describes the native pack-run + Flight Recorder evidence-spine deliverable with output URL to its DELIVERABLE
Earlier misleading duplicated completion text still exists in historical log lines, but the correction is explicitly documented and this re-check was dispatched only after Polly recorded the metadata fix.

Acceptance criteria outcome

Distinct Task 1 / Task 2 / Task 3 deliverables exist: PASS
Evidence proves logical order install -> check -> run -> route -> permissions -> evals -> Flight Recorder: PASS
Current local verification gate is reproducibly green: PASS
Mapping doc truthfulness for native 03-run.json: PASS
MC metadata for the two previously misleading tasks is corrected/documented: PASS

Quinn QA readiness

Yes. Quinn can QA now.

Exact QA commands:

cd /Users/lilly/clawd/projects/foundry-core
PYTHONPATH=src pytest -q tests/test_pack_runtime.py tests/test_cli.py tests/test_daemon.py
foundry pack install /Users/lilly/clawd/projects/foundry-commercialisation/packs/pdf-ops-pack --json
foundry pack check pdf-ops-pack --json
foundry pack run pdf-ops-pack --demo --json
foundry pack support-bundle pdf-ops-pack --json

What Quinn should see:

grouped permissions surfaced explicitly
outbound.send denied by default
routes reported declared-not-proven unless later promotion evidence exists
support bundle contains common spine plus PDF-specific evidence files
no-cloud claim backed by 12-no-cloud-posture.json